Ghostwriting & Gaslighting - Verity

GHOSTWRITING & GASLIGHTING - VERITY

WORDS BY AIMEE PRENDERGAST20 OCTOBER 2026

Director: Michael Showalter

Release: October 2nd 2026

Genre: Psychological, Erotic Thriller/ Book Adaption

There is something undeniably entertaining about a psychological thriller that keeps you guessing, throws a few unexpected twists your way, and leaves you questioning everyone on screen. Verity (2026), directed by Michael Showalter and based on Colleen Hoover’s bestselling novel, certainly understands the appeal of a story built around secrets, manipulation, and the increasingly blurred line between truth and fiction.

It is a film that wants to keep its audience guessing until the very end, and for the most part, I found myself enjoying the ride far more than I expected. However, while its twists kept me invested and its central mystery gave me plenty to think about, the film also became increasingly messy and confusing, particularly as it approached its conclusion. And while I appreciate a film that trusts its audience to make up its own mind, Verity left me with a little too many unanswered questions for my liking.

I have read some of Colleen Hoover’s books, so I went into this adaptation with a degree of hesitation. I am not her biggest fan, and one of my main reservations about her work is that I have never been entirely convinced that her stories always translate particularly well to the screen. What works on the page does not always work in a film. Sometimes, the emotional intensity that might work in a novel can feel exaggerated when brought to life by actors, while twists that are effective when reading can become less convincing when presented on screen. That was my main concern going into Verity. Fortunately, I had not read the book, and I think that made a significant difference to my experience. I went in completely blind, without knowing where the story was heading or what revelations were waiting around the corner.

I was able to experience the mystery as it unfolded rather than constantly comparing the film to its source material or anticipating particular moments. Perhaps that is one of the reasons I enjoyed it more than I otherwise might have. I was not watching to see whether the adaptation had got everything right, I was watching to find out what was going on.

The story follows Lowen Ashleigh, played by Dakota Johnson, a struggling writer who is offered an opportunity to ghostwrite the remaining books in a successful series belonging to renowned author Verity Crawford, portrayed by Anne Hathaway. Following a devastating accident, Verity is left unable to function and Lowen moves into the family home to work through the author’s material. What initially appears to be a career changing opportunity soon becomes something far more sinister when Lowen discovers a disturbing manuscript that reveals deeply troubling secrets about Verity, her marriage, and her family.

From there, the film develops into a psychological game in which nobody can be fully trusted. The more Lowen discovers, the more complicated the situation becomes. It is a compelling premise, and one that immediately lends itself to a tense, atmospheric thriller. The idea of entering somebody else’s home, discovering their private writings, and gradually uncovering secrets that could change everything is inherently unsettling. There is something particularly effective about the manuscript at the centre of the story because it introduces a question that becomes increasingly important as the film progresses, how much should we believe what we read, especially when the person who wrote it may have every reason to manipulate the truth?

This is where I really began to enjoy Verity. I enjoyed trying to piece together what was happening and deciding which characters I believed. Every new revelation encouraged me to reconsider what I thought I knew, and the film does a reasonably effective job of keeping suspicion alive. The twists are among the film’s biggest strengths. Going in blind allowed me to enjoy that sense of uncertainty, and I suspect knowing the major revelations beforehand would change the experience considerably. For all its flaws, the film kept me curious enough that I wanted to see where everything was heading.

However, there is a difference between a story that keeps you guessing and one that leaves you confused, and Verity occasionally struggles to distinguish between the two. As the plot becomes more complicated, the film introduces so many questions about its characters and their motivations that it sometimes feels as though it is creating mysteries faster than it can meaningfully develop them. The revelations are entertaining individually, but the overall narrative does not always feel as tightly constructed as it could be.

Anne Hathaway is particularly interesting as Verity. There is something inherently unsettling about a character whose presence dominates the story even when she cannot actively participate in every conversation. She brings an intensity to the role that makes it difficult to look away from her, and the uncertainty surrounding Verity becomes one of the film’s most effective sources of tension. Josh Hartnett also contributes to the film’s atmosphere of uncertainty. Jeremy is an important part of the mystery, and the relationship between him, Lowen, and Verity provides much of the film’s emotional tension. The dynamic between these characters is deliberately uncomfortable, and the film benefits from the fact that their interactions rarely feel entirely straightforward.

The atmosphere is another positive. The Crawford home provides an effective setting for a story built around secrets and mistrust. There is something unsettling about the contrast between the beautiful surroundings and the disturbing revelations emerging from within the house. It creates a sense of isolation that suits the narrative, making Lowen’s situation feel increasingly claustrophobic as she becomes more deeply involved in the family’s private affairs.

But my biggest issue with Verity is undoubtedly its ending.

I will avoid going into spoiler territory, but the conclusion left me with mixed feelings. Throughout the film, the mystery is built around the question of what is true, what is fabricated, and whether the people involved can ever be trusted. That is a perfectly compelling foundation for a psychological thriller, and I was happy to follow the story as it became more complicated. However, by the time the film reached its final moments, I wanted a little more clarity about what I had just watched. Instead, the ending leaves things sufficiently ambiguous that the audience is expected to decide for themselves what the truth might be. I understand the intention behind that approach but unfortunately, that is not quite how it worked for me here.

With Verity, I came away feeling that the film had done enough to make me question everything, but not quite enough to satisfy my desire to understand what had really happened. Rather than feeling completely intrigued by the uncertainty, I found myself frustrated by it. I wanted to know which interpretation the film was ultimately leaning towards, or at least to feel that the evidence had been arranged in a way that made one conclusion more convincing than the alternatives.

Ultimately, Verity is a film I enjoyed, but one that left me with more reservations than I would have liked. It is twisty, provocative, and entertaining enough to keep you invested, with a compelling premise and performances that help maintain the sense of unease. Going in blind undoubtedly worked in its favour for me, allowing the story to unfold naturally without the expectations that might have come from reading the book beforehand. At the same time, the messy plotting and increasingly confusing developments prevent it from becoming the consistently effective psychological thriller it could have been. The film sometimes mistakes complication for depth.

Despite those frustrations, I would not say the experience was a disappointment. I was entertained, I enjoyed the twists, and the film gave me plenty to think about. It may not have converted me into a devoted Colleen Hoover fan, but it did give me a more enjoyable adaptation experience than I had anticipated.